
I recently wrote a post for the Goodeater Collaborative. Goodeater.org is a mulit-author blog hosting dialogue and debate on how to truely eat “good food”. My post titled How Fresh Is That Fish You Are Eating explores the truth behind consumer perception of what makes seafood fresh, as wells as offers tips on how to buy the “freshest” seafood. The post has received a bounty of wonderful comments and stories so it would be a shame for this go unnoticed. In the interest of keeping our readers as informed as possible, I figured I would link to one great fresh versus frozen story here.

I recently wrote a post for the
Helen Rennie, who has offered many great comments on the site, runs a wonderful website called Beyond Salmon. The subtitle “everything you ever wanted to know about fish and other musings on all things yummy” does a very accurate job of summing up her website as the stories are both mouthwatering and informative. In one of her posts she freezes and thaws various market bought fish species in order to determine how well they hold up post-freezing. Below is an exercpt from the article (click here to read the entire article):
“There is nothing I hate more than being wrong. That’s why I research things to death to make sure that I am not wrong too often. When it does happen though, it’s a great learning experience, like the one I just got on freezing fin fish.
I kept procrastinating posting my frozen fish findings, but a question that Matthew Amster-Burton, a columnist on Culinate.com has just posted on my How to store fish story has inspired me to finally get off my lazy butt and write up my frozen fish experiments.
I used to be of the conviction that frozen fish was ALWAYS worse than fresh. I know, I know — Whole Foods and many fish cookbooks like to tell you that previously frozen fish can be even fresher than not previously frozen fish because it was frozen at the peak of freshness. Just so that I don’t have to use the “not previously frozen” terminology (that just takes too long to type), I’ll use the word “fresh” to refer to fish that did not undergo the freezing process. The question I’ll try to answer is whether previously frozen fish can taste as good as fresh, not whether it’s as safe to eat.”












